Random question about the Twilight characters Edward Cullen and Jacob Black.?

I know this never happened in the series but if it did who do you guys think would win in a Jacob and Edward fight? The upside that Edward has is the fact he can read minds so that’s an advantage on his part; but when Jacob phases he is like 10 bigger than Edward. So who do you guys think would win?


Eclipse Merchandise at HotTopic.com

Comments (10) »

  • Steffi says:

    ew. ew. and oh yeah ew.

    Sorry. If I had to choose, it’ll be jacob.

  • Eman A says:

    Edward. Hands down. :)

  • Ashley says:

    I think Edward would have the advantage because of the mind reading. But, Bella could kick both their butts.

  • Victoria A.C. says:

    Obviously, Edward would win, because SM gives them every power she can possibly think of, and makes it so that wolves could only take down vamps in a pack. So unfair, right? And even if Edward couldn’t read minds, he’d win. Besides Edward could ‘outshine’ Jacob any day. Any day that’s sunny. :P I know, lame. :P

    -V ;)

  • A R says:

    Jacob for sure! That’s what he’s made for is to kill people like Edward!

  • xoxoSarahCamronxoxo says:

    Harry Potter.

  • Chipsy says:

    Aragorn.

    Well, ok, fine, Edward, because there is only one way he can actually die- by tearing him to shreds. His body regenerates from any other injury (like Woverine’s body!). Jacob could die from anything.

  • Beth says:

    if they fought their family/pack would probably help too. and at the end of breaking dawn, there are about 10 wolves, which outnumbers the cullens. however if your talking about before all the ‘drama’ in breaking dawn, then the cullens outnumber the wolves. one on one however, yeah jacob is designed to kill vampires so id say jacob. he might hold back with bella in mind though. so basically, I DONT KNOW ITS EVEN :)

  • Anwar says:

    Definitely Harry Potter. If it has to be non-human, then Remus Lupin.

  • izzy12 says:

    Although I hate Edward (and Jacob), I think Edward would win.

    Edward would most likely win because he has the upper hand with mind-reading skills, two hands, and is smarter and more experienced than Jacob…not to mention that his venom will kill werewolves immediately.

Leave a comment

XHTML– Allowed tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wpburn.com wordpress themes